I almost passed on screening this documentary. I'm quite interested in new innovative effective improvements in education, but it seemed to me that a classroom of only 10 kids would simply be unsustainable toward real educational reformation no matter how terrific the program. But, darn-it, the optimistic idealism of the synopsis needled at me until I decided I didn't want to miss taking a look at something terrific. Boy, I'm glad I did take a look. What a wonderful documentary this is! It's splendidly-lovingly crafted like the projects created by the handful of students lucky enough to have snatched up the opportunity to work under two sincerely inspired, dedicated and talented young educators. The documentary captures their trials and tribulations and succeeds in making viewers emotionally invested, even if not all of the recipients of Emily and Matt's hard work take that leap.
I loved the film. I was glued to it heart, head and soul. I'm a huge advocate of excellent teachers, and where there are resources my philosophy is "Give great teachers what they ask for, and then get out of their way." That said, there were a few more topics I would have liked to have seen included: 1) The only arguments presented on behalf of the district were political. While, it's likely those arguments have merit, it's really not fair to ignore any practical non-biased reasons some on the board may have wanted to put their financial resources elsewhere. 2) Despite the title, the film doesn't "swell" with the implied "They will come." 3) I was left wondering if any of the town's people brainstormed ways to support this program. They could have at least provided housing and meals for the teachers (fixed their vehicles, etc.).
Still, it's an "A" all the way around. Beautifully filmed and edited. An "A+" to Matt and Emily -- if they come to your town, embrace them, find a way to allow them to help you build community!
-- Books by Author/Illustrator Ross Anthony --
|